Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Arson suspect in Bidwell Mansion fire changes his plea from not guilty to no contest

Butte County District Attorney Mike Ramsey releases new details in the investigation during a press conference after the arraignment in Chico, Calif on Jan. 6, 2024.
Erik Adams
/
NSPR
District Attorney Mike Ramsey presents information about the suspected Bidwell Mansion arsonist at a press conference in Oroville on Jan. 6, 2024.

The man charged with felony arson for the Bidwell Mansion fire changed his plea in court today.

Kevin Alexander Carlson had previously pleaded not guilty at an arraignment hearing in January.

Today’s court date was originally meant to check in on the status of the case. But when Carlson appeared, he entered a plea of no contest to the charges.

Butte County District Attorney Mike Ramsey said the proceeding was straightforward and short.

“[He] said that he wished to admit his guilt by pleading no contest to a felony count of arson to a structure with use of an accelerant,” Ramsey said. “The plea of no contest in a felony matter has the exact same legal effect as a guilty plea.”

Carlson changed his plea without making a deal with prosecutors. Pleading no contest is not an admission of guilt even though it results in a conviction.

The case will now proceed directly to a sentencing hearing on March 5. Carlson could serve a maximum of 11 years in prison.

Ramsey pointed out that the sentence would have been much longer under a recently-passed state proposition.

“He committed this arson one week to the day before Prop 36 became in effect,” Ramsey said. “If he had committed it one week later, when Prop 36 was in effect, he'd be looking at an additional 14 years.”

Ramsey said he’s not surprised by the defendant’s plea given the amount of evidence that had been collected. Ramsey said Carlson’s public defender indicated that after his client reviewed the massive amount of evidence against him, he decided to avoid a lengthy and public trial.

Ramsey said it will save his office thousands of hours of work preparing for a trial.

Ken came to NSPR through the back door as a volunteer, doing all the things that volunteers do. Almost nothing – nothing -- in his previous work experience suggests that he would ever be on public radio.
Emily is a writer and teacher with a master’s degree in Rhetoric, Literacy and Composition from Chico State. She is overjoyed to join the team at NSPR as a Digital News Assistant and share her passion for words, news, and the arts with the local community.